What Japanese Commanders Really Thought About US Marines

 

image

At 06:15 on the morning of August 21, 1942, Colonel Kiyonao Ichiki stood at the edge of a coconut grove on Guadalcanal, staring across a shallow creek at the American defensive line he was about to attack. Behind him were 917 soldiers of the Imperial Japanese Army, men who had trained for years, who had advanced across Asia without defeat, and who believed, as Ichiki himself believed, that no Western force could stand against them. On the opposite side of the creek were United States Marines.

Ichiki had studied them before departure. He knew what Japanese intelligence reports said about these men. They were soft and undisciplined. They lacked the warrior spirit that defined Japanese soldiers. They would break at the first sign of a determined assault. Within approximately 6 hours, nearly 800 of Ichiki’s soldiers would be dead, and everything Japan thought it knew about American fighting men would begin to unravel.

For decades before the Pacific War, Japanese military doctrine had been built around a belief known as Yamato-damashii, the spirit of Japan. This was not merely nationalism but a foundational conviction that Japanese soldiers possessed a spiritual superiority capable of overcoming any material disadvantage. Where Western nations relied on machines, firepower, and industry, Japan relied on the indomitable will of its warriors.

The roots of this belief reached deep into ancient mythology recorded in the Kojiki and Nihon Shoki, texts that described the Japanese people as descendants of the sun goddess Amaterasu. The emperor was considered divine, a living connection to the heavens. Japanese soldiers did not simply fight for their country; they fought for a sacred bloodline extending back thousands of years. This worldview became central to Japanese military thinking in the early 20th century.

The victory over Russia in 1905 appeared to confirm everything Japanese leaders believed about themselves. A smaller Asian nation had defeated a European power through what was understood as superior fighting spirit. Russian forces with modern weapons and industrial backing had been humiliated by Japanese soldiers who demonstrated a willingness to die that their opponents could not match. The lesson drawn was clear: material strength meant nothing against men prepared to sacrifice everything for their emperor.

The Russo-Japanese War became the template for Japan’s future conflicts. Spirit would triumph over steel. Will would defeat weapons. By the 1930s, this belief had hardened into doctrine. Japanese officers were taught that Western soldiers, particularly Americans, were spiritually weak, products of a soft, materialistic culture that valued individual comfort over collective sacrifice. When faced with desperate situations, they would surrender or flee.

The early months of the Pacific War appeared to validate this view. In December 1941, Japanese forces struck the Philippines, and American and Filipino defenses collapsed within weeks. Fortified positions expected to hold for months fell in days. Bataan and Corregidor became symbols not of resistance but of catastrophic defeat, with tens of thousands of prisoners taken. At Singapore, more than 80,000 Allied troops surrendered to a Japanese force half their size in what Winston Churchill later described as the worst disaster in British military history.

Across the Dutch East Indies, Hong Kong, Burma, and Malaya, the pattern repeated. Western colonial forces crumbled in the face of Japanese soldiers who seemed to welcome death. At Wake Island, a small American garrison held out for more than 2 weeks before surrendering, but Japanese commanders viewed this as an anomaly. The Marines there, they concluded, had simply been trapped with nowhere to retreat.

From these victories, Japanese commanders drew what seemed like obvious conclusions. Americans had better equipment, larger ships, and more supplies, but they lacked the will to fight. This belief extended specifically to the United States Marine Corps. Japanese intelligence regarded the Marines as a small, poorly equipped force with no recent experience against a serious enemy. They were, in the assessment of Imperial General Headquarters, garrison troops playing at soldiering.

In 1942, the Marine Corps did indeed number fewer than 70,000 men. During the interwar years, it had fought small wars in Nicaragua, Haiti, and the Caribbean, campaigns that did not impress Japanese planners. Nothing in that record suggested that the Marines would be formidable opponents in a modern war.

What Japanese intelligence failed to recognize was the transformation the Marine Corps had undergone during the 1930s. Anticipating a Pacific conflict, Marine officers developed new doctrines for amphibious warfare, created specialized equipment, and designed training programs tailored to assaulting fortified beaches. More importantly, they fostered a culture that emphasized small-unit leadership, individual initiative, and the ability of junior Marines to continue fighting when communications failed and plans collapsed.

This culture would be tested on Guadalcanal.

When American forces landed on the island in early August 1942 and seized the airfield under construction, Colonel Ichiki was ordered to retake it. Japanese commanders instructed him to wait for the rest of his regiment before attacking. He saw no need. His first echelon of approximately 900 men would be sufficient against Marines. Major General Alexander Vandegrift, commanding the 1st Marine Division, was unaware of the contempt Japanese officers held for his men. He was preoccupied with keeping them alive.

Vandegrift was 54 years old, a veteran of campaigns in Nicaragua, Haiti, and China. He had been promised 6 months to prepare his division for combat. He received 3 weeks when Operation Watchtower, the invasion of Guadalcanal, was announced. His men were scattered across the Pacific, equipment still being unloaded in New Zealand. There was no time for proper planning, inadequate intelligence on Japanese defenses, and a rehearsal landing in the Fiji Islands that Vandegrift later described as a disaster.

On August 7, 1942, approximately 11,000 Marines landed on Guadalcanal and nearby islands. They achieved complete surprise. By nightfall on August 8, they had secured the unfinished airfield, later named Henderson Field. The landings seemed deceptively easy. Then everything changed.

On the night of August 8 and 9, a Japanese naval force annihilated the Allied cruiser screen at the Battle of Savo Island, sinking 4 cruisers and killing more than 1,000 sailors. Fearing further losses, American naval commanders withdrew, taking with them vital supplies that had not yet been unloaded. The Marines were left stranded, with limited ammunition, limited food, and no naval support.

They dug in around Henderson Field, scavenged Japanese rice, completed the airstrip with captured equipment, and waited for the counterattack. The jungle was oppressive, filled with disease and heat. Within weeks, illness disabled more Marines than enemy fire. Still, they held.

On August 20, the first American aircraft landed at Henderson Field. The next night, Colonel Ichiki came ashore with his detachment and began his march inland, convinced that the Marines would collapse at the first assault.

They would not.

Colonel Ichiki’s force landed at Taivu Point on the night of August 19, 1942. Japanese aerial reconnaissance had reported little visible American activity on Guadalcanal, and a senior staff officer from Rabaul had personally flown over the Marine perimeter earlier in the month, concluding that the Americans had largely withdrawn. Imperial headquarters believed that only a token garrison remained, perhaps no more than 2,000 men. In reality, more than 11,000 Marines occupied the island.

Ichiki did not know this, and even had he known, it would likely not have altered his decision. His faith in the superiority of Japanese soldiers was absolute. His unit, the 28th Infantry Regiment, had originally been designated for the assault on Midway Island before the naval defeat redirected it to the Solomons. These men were among the best-trained troops in the Imperial Japanese Army, prepared for the most demanding operations. Ichiki left 125 men behind as a rear guard and marched inland with the remainder, ignoring explicit orders to wait for the rest of his regiment, which would arrive days later aboard slower transports.

What Ichiki did not realize was that the Marines had been warned. A coastwatcher named Jacob Vouza, a former sergeant major in the British Solomon Islands Police Force, had been captured by Japanese troops while gathering intelligence. When the Japanese discovered an American flag hidden in his loincloth, they demanded information about Marine positions. Vouza refused. He was tied to a tree and used for bayonet practice, stabbed repeatedly in the arms, throat, shoulder, face, chest, and abdomen. Left for dead, he chewed through his bindings after the Japanese departed and crawled for miles through the jungle, bleeding heavily, until he reached the Marine lines. He arrived with minutes to spare, warning of the imminent attack.

At approximately 01:30 on August 21, Ichiki launched his assault across the sandbar at the mouth of Alligator Creek, misidentified on American maps as the Tenaru River. Japanese soldiers charged screaming across the open ground, bayonets fixed, confident that the Americans would flee in panic. This was how Japanese attacks had succeeded throughout Asia.

The Marines did not run.

Machine gun positions along the creek opened fire with devastating accuracy. Water-cooled .30-caliber guns cut down the assault waves as they crossed the exposed sandbar. Artillery batteries, pre-registered on the approaches, dropped shells directly into the attacking formations. The sandbar became a killing ground. Japanese soldiers fell in the dozens, then in the hundreds.

When some attackers reached the Marine lines, they were met with close combat that matched their own ferocity. Marines fought with rifles, pistols, bayonets, and bare hands, giving ground only grudgingly before counterattacking to reclaim lost positions. One machine gunner, Private Al Schmid, was wounded early in the fighting when a grenade exploded near his position, blinding him permanently. Guided by his assistant gunner, Schmid continued firing throughout the night, operating his weapon by touch alone until dawn.

By sunrise, the assault had failed completely. Ichiki’s men had gained nothing except catastrophic losses. Vandergrift ordered a counterattack. Marines crossed the creek upstream and swung behind the surviving Japanese, supported by light M3 Stuart tanks. The encirclement was methodical and brutal. Japanese soldiers who attempted to flee were shot. Others fought to the last round or committed suicide. Tanks rolled through the coconut grove, crushing wounded men beneath their tracks.

By late afternoon on August 21, the battle was over. Of Ichiki’s original 917 soldiers, approximately 800 were dead. Marine casualties numbered 35 killed and 75 wounded. The exchange rate defied everything Japanese doctrine predicted. Ichiki burned his regimental colors to prevent their capture and then either died in the final fighting or committed suicide; accounts differ, but he did not survive to explain the disaster.

When reports reached Rabaul and Tokyo, disbelief followed. Japanese commanders refused to accept that an elite infantry detachment had been annihilated by American Marines. The conclusion was not that their assumptions were wrong, but that Ichiki had committed too few men. The solution, they believed, was to send more.

Major General Kiyotake Kawaguchi was assigned command of the next effort. He would lead approximately 6,000 men of the 35th Infantry Brigade, veterans of campaigns in Borneo and the Philippines. Kawaguchi was more thoughtful than Ichiki and studied the Tenaru battle carefully. He understood that frontal assaults across open ground were futile. Instead, he planned a night attack from the south, advancing through jungle terrain to strike the Marine perimeter where it appeared weakest.

A narrow ridge leading toward Henderson Field offered a potential avenue of approach. If his forces seized it, they could overrun the airfield. In September 1942, the ridge had no name. After the battle, it would be known as Edson’s Ridge, or Bloody Ridge.

The march to the assault positions proved far more difficult than anticipated. Jungle terrain shattered unit cohesion. Trails vanished, streams blocked movement, and dense vegetation disrupted command and control. Many units arrived exhausted, hungry, and disorganized. American aircraft destroyed barge convoys carrying heavy weapons, depriving Kawaguchi of artillery support. Still, he remained confident that Japanese fighting spirit would prevail.

Defending the ridge were approximately 800 Marines, primarily from the 1st Raider Battalion and the 1st Parachute Battalion under Lieutenant Colonel Merritt A. Edson. These were highly trained troops experienced in aggressive patrolling and close combat. Edson, a veteran of Nicaragua known as “Red Mike,” positioned his men carefully and registered artillery on likely approach routes. He suspected an attack was coming.

On the night of September 12, Kawaguchi launched his assault.

Japanese soldiers advanced in waves through the darkness, screaming their battle cries as they charged up the ridge toward the Marine positions. Flares illuminated the jungle, turning the night into a chaos of shadows, muzzle flashes, and explosions. The fighting that followed on Bloody Ridge became some of the most intense close combat of the Pacific War. Japanese troops repeatedly breached sections of the Marine line, forcing the defenders back toward their final positions overlooking Henderson Field itself. For hours, the outcome hung in the balance.

Lieutenant Colonel Merritt Edson moved constantly along the ridge under fire, rallying his men and directing counterattacks. When Marines began to give ground, Edson stood in the open, shouting orders and pointing to the ridge behind them, telling them that this ground could not be lost. Artillery fire, precisely called in by forward observers, smashed into Japanese assault formations, breaking up attacks before they could fully develop. When ammunition ran low, Marines fought with bayonets and rifle butts. Hand-to-hand combat erupted in multiple sectors as Japanese soldiers who penetrated the perimeter were hunted down and killed.

During the second night of fighting, Japanese troops advanced so close to Henderson Field that American personnel began preparing to destroy aircraft rather than allow them to be captured. Yet the assault gradually lost momentum. Exhaustion, mounting casualties, and relentless Marine resistance took their toll. By dawn on September 14, Kawaguchi’s offensive had failed. More than 600 Japanese soldiers lay dead on the ridge and in the surrounding jungle. Hundreds more were wounded. The survivors retreated westward in small groups, many of them starving, to begin a march that would kill hundreds more through disease, hunger, and exhaustion.

Major General Alexander Vandegrift later acknowledged that Kawaguchi’s assault was the only moment during the Guadalcanal campaign when he seriously doubted the outcome. Had the ridge fallen, the Marines might have lost Henderson Field and with it the island. Historian Richard B. Frank would later write that the Japanese never came closer to victory on Guadalcanal than during those September nights on the ridge that would forever bear Edson’s name.

The defeats of Ichiki and Kawaguchi should have forced a fundamental reassessment within the Japanese command. Instead, denial prevailed. Japanese military culture discouraged open acknowledgment of failure, and officers who admitted mistakes risked disgrace. Rather than confronting the possibility that their assumptions about American fighting capability were wrong, Japanese leaders concluded that previous assaults had simply lacked sufficient force.

Lieutenant General Harukichi Hyakutake, commander of the 17th Army, arrived on Guadalcanal in October 1942 to oversee a final, decisive offensive. He brought with him the 2nd Sendai Division, a prestigious formation with extensive combat experience in Manchuria and China. More than 20,000 Japanese troops were assembled for a coordinated assault intended to overwhelm the Marine perimeter once and for all. Naval bombardment and air attacks were planned to neutralize Henderson Field before the ground assault began. Hyakutake’s staff was so confident that preparations were made for accepting the American surrender.

The decisive battle was scheduled for October 23. Hyakutake informed his superiors that the moment of final reckoning between Japan and the United States had arrived. In that sense, he was correct. But the outcome would not favor Japan.

The October offensive began with attacks along the Matanikau River, where Japanese tanks advanced under cover of darkness. Marines armed with 37 mm anti-tank guns waited until the vehicles were close, then destroyed them one by one. Infantry following the tanks were cut down by machine gun fire. The main assault, however, came from the south, where the Sendai Division struck the Marine lines.

At one critical sector, Sergeant John Basilone commanded two sections of heavy machine guns. Over the course of the night, his position was attacked by approximately 3,000 Japanese soldiers. Basilone fought without rest, repairing jammed weapons under fire, carrying ammunition through enemy-infested ground, and manning guns himself when his crews were killed or wounded. At times, the bodies of fallen Japanese piled so high in front of his position that Marines had to push them aside to clear fields of fire. By the time reinforcements arrived, Basilone and only two other Marines from his section remained standing. He would later receive the Medal of Honor for his actions.

Similar scenes unfolded across the perimeter. Lieutenant Colonel Lewis B. Puller’s battalion held under repeated assaults. Japanese attacks followed predetermined plans that officers were unwilling to alter even when they failed. When Puller later asked a Japanese prisoner why tactics were not changed once it became clear the attacks were failing, the answer was simple: the plan had been made, and no one would dare change it.

The October offensive collapsed. Japanese casualties ranged between 2,200 and 3,000 dead. American casualties were fewer than 300 killed and wounded. The Sendai Division was shattered. For the first time, Japanese commanders began to consider the possibility that Guadalcanal could not be retaken.

As 1942 drew to a close, the island became known among Japanese soldiers as Starvation Island. The Tokyo Express destroyer runs could not deliver enough supplies to sustain the troops. American control of Henderson Field made daylight resupply impossible. Soldiers resorted to eating roots, grass, and tree bark. Disease swept through the ranks. Once-strong units disintegrated into starving remnants. Japanese soldiers developed grim measures of survival, judging how long a man had left to live based on his ability to stand, sit, speak, or blink.

In December 1942, Hyakutake sent a desperate message to Tokyo, requesting permission to launch a final suicidal assault rather than die slowly of hunger. Admiral Isoroku Yamamoto himself compared the situation on Guadalcanal to the siege of Port Arthur in the Russo-Japanese War, a comparison that revealed how completely the campaign had exceeded Japanese expectations.

In early February 1943, Japanese forces evacuated Guadalcanal in Operation Ke, extracting approximately 10,600 survivors over three nights. They left behind more than 14,000 dead from combat and another 9,000 from disease and starvation. For every American killed on the island, nearly 10 Japanese soldiers had died. Japan’s finest infantry units had been consumed.

The most significant loss, however, was not measured in casualties or ships sunk. It was the destruction of a belief. Guadalcanal shattered the conviction that Japanese spiritual superiority could overcome any enemy. The Marines had proven that Americans could fight, could hold their ground, and could match Japanese ferocity in close combat. The assumption that aggressive night attacks would cause American lines to collapse was proven false.

From Guadalcanal onward, Japanese commanders would face opponents who would not break. In such a war, American industrial capacity, logistics, and adaptability would prove decisive. The Marines on Guadalcanal had not set out to change history. They were fighting disease, hunger, and relentless attacks simply to survive. But in holding Henderson Field, they altered the course of the Pacific War.

Major General Alexander Vandegrift received the Medal of Honor for his leadership. Lieutenant Colonel Merritt Edson received the same for his defense of Bloody Ridge. Sergeant John Basilone became a national hero and later returned to combat, where he was killed on Iwo Jima. The 1st Marine Division was so ravaged by combat and disease that it required months to recover before returning to battle, carrying with it the legacy of Guadalcanal.

For Japan, the campaign marked the end of expansion and the beginning of irreversible decline. For the Marines, it established a reputation that would endure for generations. Guadalcanal became sacred ground, the place where American forces proved that Japanese commanders had been wrong about everything that mattered.

Guadalcanal was where the tide turned. It was where the myth of Japanese invincibility died. It was where the Pacific War became a war Japan could no longer win.